You guys I finished my second jacket of the month…check me out….I am on fire!!! hahaha
This is my first attempt at the incredibly popular Minoru jacket. I say first because I made this straight out of the envelope and overall I am pretty pleased with the finished garment, but, well, if I make this again I would probably tweak it slightly and maybe make it in a more exciting fabric. Does it look a little dull to you? Navy and grey? Zzzzzz
Kapow! I jazzed up the main body of the lining with a bright pink cotton lining with little grey elephants all over it.
Can we spend a minute talking about zips? Specifically, are the only zips worth buying YKK zips? Initially I ordered a metal toothed open ended zip from some random ebay supplier. Said zip came (superfast), but when I examined it, it just felt cheap and not very reliable. I did some more research. What I read was that YKK zips are probably the most reliable zips you can buy; they are least likely to need replacing. So I then ordered a pair of (YKK) heavy duty open ended zips from Jaycotts. I ordered a pair because I couldn’t get a matching closed ended zip so I cut the second zip down for the hood zipper. I went for grey because I thought it would break up the navy, and pick out the grey elephants. I think it gives the jacket a little more of a sporty feel.
BTW, the outer fabric is the same waterproofed poplin that I used for Vogue 8884. Here’s my review; it’s easier to just write everything in there rather than repeating myself.
Pattern Review
Pattern Description:
The Minoru Jacket is a zip-front weekend jacket with a secret hood hidden inside the wide collar! If you prefer, skip the hood and let the dramatic collar be the focus. Flattering raglan sleeves are comfortable and easy-to-sew, and the elastic waistline creates a slim, curve-hugging silhouette.
No need to choose between having a hood OR a cute collar. The hood is tucked away in the wide, roomy collar, ready for when you need it, but stays hidden when you don’t! The collar looks great done up or left open. The jacket is fully lined, with interior patch pockets to stash your cards and keys safely and out of sight.
Practical and pretty!
Pattern Sizing:
0 – 16
Did it look like the photo/drawing on the pattern envelope once you were done sewing with it?
Yes.
Were the instructions easy to follow?
Yes. There is also a great (very detailed) sewalong with some extras in it, like how to line the hood and how to machine the lining to the cuffs, rather than slipstitching.
What did you particularly like or dislike about the pattern?
This really is a great pattern which sews up so well! I love the elastic in the waist which gives a more feminine silhouette. I love that it is such a practical pattern but you can customise it in so many different ways.
Things I dislike:
First off the printing on the pattern is waaaaaaaay too light. I mean, seriously, annoyingly light. Barely readable light. And there are others who have noticed the same thing. When you are paying a premium price for an independent pattern I think that’s a poor deal.
The window marked on the pattern piece is too big for the 18 inch zipper. Fortunately I read about this on another blog before I came to sewing this part (so it didn’t annoy me as such – just pointing it out) – and anyway, I had a longer length zipper which I cut to size (on account of having to order two open ended zippers to get matching ones for the jacket front and the collar/ hood opening).
There are no outer pockets on the jacket. Again, this wasn’t a big deal for me. I added in inseam pockets 1.5 inches below the waist elastic using this tutorial. But for a beginner this may be somewhat off putting.
Fabric Used:
Waterproofed poplin outer, printed cotton lining for main body of jacket, acetate (?) lining for sleeves and heavy duty open ended zips.
Pattern alterations or any design changes you made:
I lined the hood using the sewalong instructions.
I chose to bind the raw, unfinished edge of the hood/ collar (concealed inside the hood compartment).
I interfaced the collar (the instructions don’t tell you to do this).
I added inseam pockets 1.5 inches below the waist elastic.
I machine stitched the lining to the cuffs. This meant this jacket involved zero hand stitching – yeah! TBH I think Tasia’s instructions for this part of the sewalong are a little confusing (no offence Tasia if you read this), and I used Grainline’s tutorial on bagging a lining instead.
I omitted the internal pockets – I have no use for them.
One thing to watch out for; one of my plackets ended up being longer than the other and I had to go back and even them up (which meant unpicking some topstitching). Others on PR.com have commented on a similar experience.
Would you sew it again? Would you recommend it to others?
Yes, I might sew this again. It’s such a great pattern to have in the collection. Minor tweaks next time would be to possibly shorten length/ shorten sleeves and grade in at bottom of jacket. Yes, I highly recommend.
Conclusion:
Make this pattern if you want to invoke jealousy in others around you….be warned. 🙂
The jacket is very neatly sewn. You did a GREAT job in it. Love it.
Thanks bike!
You did a fantastic job! I love the elephant fabric on the inside! ~Laurie
Thanks Laurie.
Your sewing is impeccable. Although the navy and grey, as you said are a bit boring, you have certainly brightened it up with your elephant lining. A truly beautiful jacket that you should wear with pride.
Thanks Jean Margaret.
You did a great job on this! The blue is basic and functional…. I can also see it in something fun and lively. Well done!
Thanks Roberta.
One of the nicest versions of this jacket I’ve seen. Lovely fabric choices and I really like the contrast zip.
Thanks Liz.
I would be jealous of it too. Great Minoru. Thanks for the heads up on all the hiccups you encountered. This pattern is still on my must-sew list.
Thanks melizza. I can see everyone having a need for a minoru in their closet 🙂
I really like your jacket. In fact, I think I have enjoyed everything you’ve posted. You have a great eye for matching pattern style with fabric. Since we have similar body shapes, I am going to start taking my sewing cues from you. Is that weird? I don’t care if it is weird. After I finish up what’s on my cutting table right now, I am going to go through your blog and pick out the patterns I already have, go through my stash and have at it. Thanks for all the great inspiration!
Thanks tcue. Very flattered that you are that inspired by what I have made. Hope you are pleased with your finished garments.
This coat is so flattering on everyone I have seen. The nipped in waist and waterproof fabric / hood combo just make it perfect. Fantastic job .
Thanks Lisa. I got the fabric for this jacket and the vogue trench from carlisle covered market.
Brilliant job, I cannot believe that last week I saw the red coat you had made and already you have made this so beautifully. I do not buy branded zips because I buy from Birmingham rag market one stall has three big boxes of zips to rummage through at 3 zips for a £1. Whenever I am in I call in and stock up. If I am not in Birmingham for work, I have had excellent zips off eBay.
PS how did you tell by looking at the fabric it would be waterproof?
Rachel
Thanks Rachel. The fabric for both coats were labelled as waterproof poplin. I did a little test of my own on a sample and water seemed to just bead and run off. But the proof will come when I wear the minoru out on one of our wet Cumbrian days!
It is perfect. I love it. I have the pattern, and should make it!
Thanks Kay. Do it.
Beautiful!
Thanks Alethia.
Great Minarou! “Boring” will do you well when you want to grab a jacket and run out and not worry about matching. I bet you get a LOT of use from this one. Too bad the light printing wasn’t caught in quality control, either at the printer or by the pattern company during a press check or later. I don’t think indies should be given more leeway, since the higher prices should cover things like this. I’m more willing to give the Big 3/4 a break when I’m only paying $2-4 a pattern (only buy during sales). Uh oh … going off on a little rant again. 🙂
Haha thanks Debbie. Yep I know where you are going with your rant 🙂
So in love with the elephants! Fabulous coat 🙂
Thanks Kristin.
Love your jacket and top stitching details! I made this jacket last year and used a waterproof material that I now find too stiff. Stiff wearable but not as comfortable. Yours looks softer and more comfortable to wear! Good job!
Thanks Diana.
Your jacket is lovely. Cute lining 🙂
Can I ask where you got your waterproofed poplin from ? I have also just bought this very same pattern and Im struggling for fabric! Thanks 🙂 x
Hi dawn I bought it from my local market in carlisle and I don’t think there is any left! I will post a msg if I can think of anywhere else to source!
Aww thats a pity, but thank you 🙂 x
Pingback: Simplicity 2479: DIY mens quilted body warmer vest | sewmanju
Pingback: Minoru Jacket Take Two: DIY Khaki Waterproof Hooded Jacket Anorak | sewmanju
Years late but just been searching for a good coat to make during this rainy New Year we’re having and came across your version. I’ve read lots of your posts and we have a similar shape so you’ve definitely inspired me to add this to my to make pile! I hope you got lots of wear out of it!